Journey: The Soul Sandwich


This is a topic that comes up fairly often here on iblogwhatihear, the intersection of political science, social issues, and popular music. The band Journey has suddenly become the band of the moment. It began with The OC, and continues to this day. It’s a mix of Marc Wahlberg style Hollywood drama, with a sort of retro 80’s nostalgia. Needless to say, it all makes me very uncomfortable.

This morning, as has become a habit I am neither proud of nor apologetic for, I was watching The Today Show. Their guest was Journey, obviously just for the kitsch factor. Leading up to the segment all week they were asking fans to “Wear your most outrageous 80’s gear and text in the hits you want to hear, as requested by the band!” Really? Have you guys become that much of a caricature of yourselves? Your place in history is already set as phenomenal musicians, songwriters, and performers, please just hang it up before you come out of this one looking not so hot (too late.)


Let’s do a short review, so you don’t have to read the Wikipedia entry: Journey began as a prog rock band founded by guitar player Neal Schon and other former members of Santana’s band, shredding to their hearts content and achieving minimal commercial success. Steve Perry joined the band, and the world exploded in a massive cloud of falsetto vocals and unstoppable hits. They pioneered the arena rock movement. Insert typical band drama, Perry leaves, band breaks up, re-forms, but Perry has medical issues and cannot tour, Schon replaces him, and the rest is history. Well, sort of. They replaced him with a nearly identical singer, Steve Augeri, in both looks and tone (His name even sounds kind of similar!) Several years later, after the massive commercial resurgence, Augeri is replaced with vocalist Arniel Pineda, who was found in a Journey cover band on You Tube! WHAT!? Yes, its true.

No, thats not Perry, it's Augeri
No, thats not Perry, it's Augeri

OK, so lets examine this matter from a few angles. I understand they wanted to take advantage of their recent commercial success after years of dormancy. I also understand that personal conflicts, of which none of us have any understanding play into this, and the band doesn’t want to re-form with Perry, or who knows what. Really, Rock Star with Marky Mark is a fantastic film, if for no other reason than Zakk Wylde and Jason Bonham. But I don’t want to see it reenacted in real life with a band I love and respect.


It just feels a little bit like Schon is trapped in his head and has an image of himself as a rock guitar god. He’s certainly entitled to this image, he played one of the most memorable guitar solos ever created, but for some reason it just doesn’t add up. He seems like a dude your dad hangs out with, attempting to dress like his image of what a “cool young guy” dresses like, in the year 1996. There’s just something about him that doesn’t compare to Jimmy Page, Jeff Beck, Duane Allman, any of those guys. Even Steve Vai, or any of the other note cramming shredders, Schon just doesn’t seem to fit in. Maybe he’s too buff – like he spends as much time in the weight room as he does on stage.


Just for one second though, can we appreciate the pure magic of this band? We’re not even going to discuss “Don’t Stop Believin” because we have already discussed that. “Separate Ways”? That’s a phenomenal song. “Lights”? Straight up magical. “Wheel In The Sky”, “Any Way You Want It”, “Lovin Touchin Squeezin”, “Open Arms”, “Faithfully”, we could really be here all day. Its a mix of just enough 1980’s shiny polished cheese based bravado…and amazing songs. At the core of it, all of these songs are perfect. They could be played with one guitar and a voice, and bring you to that place where your soul is fed a delicious sandwich at all times. They are the Soul Sandwich™ (I just coined that term, feel free to use it, with proper credit given.)

Couldn’t you guys just leave it alone? I just heard recently The Faces are doing a “Reunion Tour” only without Rod Stewart. Yeah, that’s right. There’s a reason the Beatles never reunited without Lennon. If it’s solely about the money, do as Van Halen, The Eagles and all those other classic rockers do, just get separate buses and play arenas with separate dressing rooms. Here’s a concept: start a new type of arena tour, with 5 separate stages for each member, so you don’t even have to be on stage together! It will revolutionize live performance. Think about it Schon, you have my number.

The chain wallet was totally necessary, Schon
The chain wallet was totally necessary, Schon

How does Perry feel about all this? He’s been hiding in the wings recently, hanging out off the radar. Except when he decides to attend a Giants game and sing “Don’t Stop Believin” with the crowd. For real. But how can his heart not be broken? He seems like an emotional being, and I must admit, I feel for him. Here is something you helped create and were the face of, out gallivanting doing the talk show circuit dressed like uncomfortable dads trying to fit in at a Nickelback concert, and there is nothing you can do about it. I can’t help but think that if Perry were involved, there would be no costumes or hoopla, just pure songs.

It just feels like an opportunity has been missed. Journey could have been The Stones. Well, maybe not the stones, but certainly taken more seriously than they are right now. Being a kitsch act is totally cool if that’s your thing. I genuinely love Weird Al, who doesn’t? But had they stepped back in with Perry, and not went the large scale cover band route, it seems as if they could have at least been America’s version of The Who. So please, think of your legacy. Do it for the Soul Sandwich

6 thoughts on “Journey: The Soul Sandwich”

  1. I was not a die hard fan of Journey in the 70’s or 80’s but I knew that it was them whenever I heard one of their songs, be it on the radio, at a party, anywhere, and why was that? It was because of Steve Perry’s indistinct voice. Just as in Led Zeppelin, they should have called it quits, or better yet, get a new singer and make new songs for that particular singer, then it wouldn’t have been so douchy on their end. I think this is also what prevented Neil from being know as a great guitar player, same old songs and too much drama, without knowing, he himself is the sole responsible of ruining his career. People will ALWAYS think of Perry as the great voice of Journey.

  2. True, true, true. I like your humor. No one sums up the emotional highs of those times like Journey did. I still glow from the memories. Perry took the high road and bless him for it.

  3. Thank you! I’m a junior in high school and just got really into Journey in the last two months or so, probably a little less, and that love for Journey has expanded to Steve Perry becoming my idol. Watching videos of them in the 80s performing live (thank you Youtube) and seeing pictures of them all together, I always thought that Neal Schon looked like the weird creepy guy that everyone kind of avoids when they see someone like him. It was just a hunch, so I neve said anything, but I’ve been pretty curious about if it’s just me or if anyone else sees it too. I’m glad I’m not the only one who doesn’t have the best opinion of him. But he definitely deserves some mad props and respect for his guitar skills; you really just can’t deny that. So just thank you for posting this, it kind of made my day. Somewhat sad right? Well I’m also in a high school full of a thousand couples on Valentines Day, and I’m siting in the library, being Team Single.
    Just a quick question for anyone who can answer, the picture at the top isn’t one I’ve seen before and I’m having a little bit of trouble figuring out who’s who (I know who Steve Perry is though), so could someone just tell me the names of the members in the picture from left to right or something? Much appreciated!

  4. Yes it is true that Steve Perry is the original singer but good musicians will not stop playing their instruments. When the band broke up or disbanded, they just rest for a couple of months and regroup again cause they missed their love in music. Imagine if four of them will continue playing music without a singer. And that is the reason why an unknown singer from third world country was discovered because his voice fit the band perfectly on what the old band members is looking for. I avid fan of Journey during Steve days and I would like to hear and hear and hear Journey up to now but when Steve departed and made his own way, and when I heard the new front man fit very well with Journey’s music i am still love hearing their music with the new front man, in fairness to this asian guy, he has a very powerful voice and a very good frontman.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>